Tuesday, October 07, 2008

take back the city



last tuesday i went to a listening party for the new snow patrol album, a hundred million suns, at bar marmont, of the legendary chateau marmont hotel. i got there just in time to grab a drink, meet the publicist, run into a couple of friends, and hear jimmy iovine give a speech about how great the album is and what a fabulous job the band and the producer did, etc.

i was chatting with someone who said the band is in the u.s. associated with grey's anatomy a lot -- i guess b/c "chasing cars" was featured on that show. it's funny to me, b/c i think of snow patrol as a band of torchwood and doctor who, since on different eps i've heard SP songs like "spitting games," "chocolate," and "chasing cars." and maybe others.

anyway. a few days ago i made a playlist of '80s new-wave rock: bow wow wow, madness, greg kihn band, the cars, dave edmunds, rockpile, squeeze, etc. i've been playing it a lot on my ipod on my bitchen new car stereo. so, isn't it funny that snow patrol's new single, "take back the city," totally fits the mood of that playlist? it sounded really good coming out of the speakers super-loud at the bar, and i definitely could hear it blasting in the beast. it reminds me of a cars song, except not as synthy -- but still it's all urban-sleek and kind of bouncy and elastic, and burbly-propulsive, with some really angular guitar moments. and it has a nice blend of romanticism and cynicism while celebrating la vie moderne:

i love the city tonight
i love the city always
it bares its teeth like a light
and spits me out after days


yeah, so that's their flavor-of-the-moment tune, maybe. but the album also has the moodier, more ethereal and pensive numbers they do so well. i liked it as i heard it, but can't wait to get a closer listen. it's out here october 28. and snow patrol will be doing a show in london while i'm in the UK -- on the 27th. i wish i could go! but i'm planning on being in bath that day ... and it's about two hours away from london. that seems like sort of a haul, especially since they'll be in socal later this year. to be honest, i had some issues when i saw them live at the greek in july '07. but i'd still like to see them again.

Monday, October 06, 2008

golden age



ok, this post is waaaay overdue, but ... on september 24 at USC's annenberg school, i participated in this panel called "death of the critic?" it's not the sort of thing i usually do -- mainly b/c i don't get asked -- but this time i was invited by l.a. times pop music critic ann powers, so i had to say yes. i was kind of freaked out by the thought of doing it. as much as i like to talk, i am not that big a fan of talking to a room full of people. but it turned out to be not so bad -- although i definitely felt like a lightweight amid that bunch of academics, book writers, big-time critics, and a pulitzer prize-winner.

the panel went on for two hours, and the room was packed. afterward there was a lot of conversation, and then 00soul and i and some other friends adjourned to coiledsoul's neighborhood dive frank n hanks to discuss things all over again (and to get into a weird situation with a drunk who claimed to be from norman, oklahoma ... but that's another story). then, when i woke up at 6:30 the next morning, i started thinking about the panel stuff again ... and after 00soul woke up and had his coffee, we started talking about the panel some more.

so it feels a little overwhelming to try to recapture everything that came up during the panel and the ensuing convos. there were 10 people on the panel alone, so it took a fair amount of time just for each person to say their views on the state of music criticism today, and where it might be going.

i managed to make a couple of points and not sound too much like an idiot, but for me what was really exciting about the panel was the meeting of the minds. just that many people in a room, all pondering these questions of what being a critic means, what's our role, how is it changing, how can we adapt -- plus larger points about the state of the culture, the cycles that pop music goes through as an emblem of "youth culture," the role of an authoritative critical voice in today's tower-of-babel marketplace. the music world is more fragmented and niche-driven than ever, but there are certainly still milestone albums or big acts ... even if best-sellers aren't what they used to be.

i liked hearing people's ideas and insights -- ironically, since i actually said, when asked what critics i read regularly, that i don't really care about other people's opinions (which is true, but not universally) -- and discussing things like the hive-mind of every major outlet reviewing the same album as the lead on the week it comes out (the example used was the fine new dear science by tv on the radio (pictured above), mainly b/c it's happening right now). there was some discussion of critical egos (a point brought up by ernest hardy) and how the feeling of not wanting to be out of the loop fuels the hive mentality (not that he exactly put it that way).

ernest also pointed out that the contracting of the marketplace for paid jobs for critics has constricted things even further for writers of color, and how that takes certain viewpoints or concerns out of the public conversation -- although blogs do give anyone with a notion to say something a way to say it, one of the issues we kept returning to was actually being able to make a living as a critic. anyway, ernest also noted the paradigm shift in the culture in general -- the sense, which is not only technology-driven, that we are at a crossroads, nobody knows what's going to happen next, and we're all sort of simultaneously trying to find our footing in that and trying to anticipate where we're headed. while keeping our heads above water.

i think a lot of the critics had a broader view of all that and expressed it in their opening statements, where for me i saw the question of where's rock criticism at right now as a personal one. i think that's because my career has been more subject to whim than some -- in that, (a) i spent so much of my early days doing whatever i wanted and deciding what got covered based on what i liked, and (b) after i started writing for a mainstream publication, i really became a generalist who was most comfortable being told, "ok, go there, cover that." in fact i liked it that way b/c it was so different from how i started out. it was a challenge to learn to write intelligently and fairly about things i didn't have a natural affinity for, and covering whatever for the l.a. times broadened my critical horizons in ways i probably never would have done on my own.

sure, that meant having to cover NSYNC along with getting to see erykah badu, but even the horrible/excruciating experiences added to my knowledge base. and one of the things that came up was the question of what's the use of expertise in this blog-eat-blog world. i think for readers, it depends on what they want out of a review. are you looking for someone to say whether the record is any good, or do you want to learn more about what you're listening to? some might find themselves intrigued by what a critic tells them, even if they didn't know they wanted to know whatever info's been imparted.

that said, it's doubtless at least in part snobbery that i don't really believe in the democratization of criticism. just b/c there's more people blogging about music, doesn't mean they're saying anything worthwhile or good -- and, just to be clear, i'm certainly not saying all music blogs or any given ones are worthless, b/c a lot of what i find to be really awful music criticism these days is in the mainstream publications. but more is not necessarily better ... and a lot of music blogging is along the lines of it rocked/it sucked, or how this record changed my life, rather than saying anything especially insightful. but consensus isn't that important to me ... i've never cared about being in step or thinking in line with other critics. it might be as simple as not being a baby boomer or boomlet-er -- i'm used to being outnumbered. also, when i was younger, louder, and snottier, i used to tear down boomer icons just for sport, b/c i like to argue and it was fun to enrage people with pure immature snark like saying i hate bob dylan.



hmmm ... but maybe my dylan thing is a good illustration of why critical knowledge is useful. i really didn't get his deal, and to a certain extent i still respect and admire him more than i actually like him (if that makes sense), but (mostly due to repeated beatings from my betters) my youthful knee-jerk against dylan was slowly replaced by a better understanding of him and a real appreciation for his singular contributions. ironically, i never understood some of my punker-than-thou pals who hated the beatles (hello, the ramones loved them!) ... i guess the impulse isn't much different. anyway, so, as both a fan of music and a critic of same, knowing more about a subject can be enlightening in unexpected ways. and learning about something tends to enrich one's opinion -- even if you're just a casual fan and NOT a writer.

but criticism is more than just is this record/concert good or not? it's also about placing things in the broader context of the culture and assessing What It All Means. which is also the place where shit can get pretentious as all hell, oftentimes, but i think there are ways to do it w/o sounding like a total egghead asshole. and wtf, even if you do, it's still important.

anyway, just b/c a certain number of people want to go with the consensus a la rotten tomatoes, doesn't mean criticism shouldn't aim for loftier or even more practical goals. one of my pet peeves when reading reviews is when a critic will go on about how the record isn't so great, but two songs are the bomb, and then give the thing three stars or whatever. b/c most critics don't have to pay for the album, so too often they don't think about the 18 bucks or 11 bucks or whatever someone's gonna drop on a CD with two good songs on it. anyway ... there are fans with opinions, and lord knows they are legion, but criticism isn't just about an opinion. there's also a sense of historical perspective, an inkling of where this stuff is coming from, what else is like it, where its roots might be, and how things fit together.

but none of this is to say that only print publications can provide that. i think good writing about music can be found anywhere -- maybe even in the comments on amazon.com. it's more about the writer than the venue.

speaking of star ratings, the subject came up, and we all agreed we hate them b/c they're so reductive and meaningless. i guess the argument for them is they provide a "service" to readers -- like, the consumer reports version of criticism. on one hand i don't see criticism as a service: it's an art form in itself, a way of interpreting something, just as music is a way of interpreting life or love or brand-new cadillacs or what have you. music criticism is a way of interpreting work that's not strictly verbal, since it has the musical component as well. i'm not saying i see my work as art (ahaha -- funny idea), but i don't think of myself as a consumer reporter. and i HATE ratings. hate them. we never used them at citybeat, and i wouldn't put ratings on my times reviews, except that if i didn't some editor would, and that would be even more excruciating. music isn't a restaurant or a term paper, and putting grades on albums is just stupid.

otoh, in terms of consumer service, i do see criticism as a form of journalism, which is a public trust. it's definitely not as life-or-death as, say, war reporting or writing about social ills, etc. but i do think criticism can and should look at how art reflects, sorry for the cliche, the human condition. and also critics have a responsibility to the truth. they have to assess the quality of something using the sum total of their experience and perceptions and understanding. and NOT, say, whether they'll sound really cool by comparing fall out boy to nina simone, or if they'll really be pissing off some publicist, or if they'll lose an interview with a band b/c they trashed the album. b/c, to use ANOTHER cliche, at the end of the day, i have to look at myself in the mirror, and i don't wanna be telling myself, damn, you really kissed ASS today!

what can be harder for me is to assess something w/o feeling like i am selling out my own principles. what i dislike the most about reviewing something as mainstream as, say, the jonas brothers, is that i really have a hard time just coloring inside the lines of the dominant culture.



the status-quo boy/girl crap, for example, that an act like the jonases (the jonasi?) embrace really bugs me, especially with their stuff, where the girl is seen as somewhat passive and the boy is the actor. (like that line in the song "bb good": "i don't wanna hurt you/i wanna kiss you!" ... which jim derogatis jokingly said sounded like dialogue from a date rape, much to the dismay of some, but i don't see why that's such an inappropriate comment. for one thing, it was funny. for another thing, i also found that line creepy and stalkerish. it's just the same old crap of boy has to talk girl into doing stuff she doesn't wanna do -- b/c everybody knows girls never initiate sex, don't like it anyway, and have to be "convinced" into it. yeah, or maybe she's just not that into you, creepy christian freak.) it's the worst kind of mainstream perpetuating-the-patriarchy b.s., b/c it seems sort of innocuous and plastic, but it just reinforces ideas that i hate. i usually try to say SOMETHING about the ingrained sexism of this sorta stuff, but usually i end up feeling like i'm not saying enough about the underlying propagandistic nature of it all, b/c i only have 200-300 words and have to do the job i'm expected to do (ie, say whether the album is good or bad and put some fuckin' stars on it). yeah -- sellout!

uhm ... anyway. another central point about the death of the critic was the pretty basic survival issue of how to make a living at it these days. it was never a highly paid profession, but lately, as 00soul said, it's hard to compete with free. if rock criticism is devalued now, maybe it's b/c people aren't used to paying for it -- same as music itself. i guess people who have music blogs can put ads on them, and maybe that brings in a few bucks, but i'm guessing it's not much. i refuse to work for free and always have -- one of the things that bugs me the most are the hipster bohemian indie mags that cry poverty and don't pay their writers (while, say, boosting their own brand name by putting on festivals). we want your professional opinion, but we're not willing to pay you for it! whatevs. yet, in the case of people who DO pay, some of them are lowering their already low rates: i got paid less per word for that jonas bros. review in the times than i've EVER been paid for anything i've ever done for them in 12 years.

(hilarious aside: while i was tapping away at this entry, this line ad popped up in my google mail: FreelanceWriters.info - Freelance Writers Needed. We pay $3 per 250 words. Start Now! yeah.)

on the subject of word count, another thing that came up was the shrinking copy hole -- how reviews grow ever shorter, and complaints that one cannot assess an album in 75 words or less, or that readers can't get to know how a critic thinks by reading only short pieces. idk. i agree that in-depth analysis can be important, but, frankly, i don't think the jonas brothers is worth 400 words. and i don't get why, at a time when there's less space to review something that might be artistically interesting, choices are made to devote space to, say, the new rick springfield album. well, actually, i do get why: because increasingly editors don't have the same depth of critical knowledge about the subject they're assigning as the writers do.

anyway, i think long-form criticism has its place, but sometimes you CAN dispatch something in 75 words or less. and even though the internet provides a place for critics to go on for as many words as they want, or feel is necessary, i think it's a special breed of reader who can tolerate that. internet-savvy folks know the shorthand TL/DR (too long, didn't read) -- lord knows this blog is a shining example of that at times, ahaha.

the irony of all this infinite unlimited space is that it's like inversely proportional to the attention span of most people. i know i can't stand to read painfully long reviews. i can certainly WRITE them, however. ahaha.

then came another serious question of, why should someone read a review when they can just hear the track and decide for themselves? well, i think that for a lot of people, that IS what they want: to just decide if they like something and buy or steal it. but others, people who are really engaged with the music and want to know more, will find value in reading someone's assessment of it or more info about the group or whatever (see above, about 5,000 words back). but, i mean, just b/c we have more access to images and sounds and moving pictures doesn't mean the presence of the written word is diminishing. to me it seems like there are more words than ever.

finally, we were asked what places we look (besides our own main publications, of which i don't have one) for great criticism. and, like i said up there somewhere, to be honest, i don't read much criticism. i think a lot of rock criticism is terrible writing, and also i just don't care about other people's opinions. and, since i am copy editing for a living right now, i'm doing a LOT of reading for work. so i tend to troll myspace for bands my friends have told me about, or spend time talking to them about what they like or to 00soul about whatever obscure soul 45s he's bidding for or has just won on ebay. or go out to see something when one of my rock crit pals invites me out -- like seeing cold war kids play the jimmy kimmel show with bronson, good times.

all of that said, these are some writers i like and respect: richard cromelin (late of the l.a. times) is always a good read. edna gundersen and ken barnes at usa today. this cat ben rayner at the toronto star. and the aforementioned kevin bronson, whose local-music-oriented blog buzz bands keeps me caught up.

ok, phew. there's probs more i could say, but this post took me way too long to write, so i'm gonna quit while i'm ahead. i don't think there's a transcript yet, but if one happens i will post a link to it later.

Sunday, September 21, 2008

i don't care



in the l.a. times today, lynell george had a really interesting profile of kathleen norris, whose new book is called acedia and me.

ace-what now? acedia, which apparently means "sloth" (aka one of the seven deadly sins), but it is a latin word that literally means "absence of caring." let lynell explain...

...Since her teens she'd struggled with episodes of inertia that spread into a bleak stretch of anxiousness and eventually spun out into indifference.

The first one started with a single thought that "slithered into my Eden, pulling a string of other thoughts, each one worse than the one before," she writes.

That moment would mark the beginning of a recurrence of "bleak moods," but it wouldn't be until Norris reached her 30s that she ran across a word -- acedia -- in the writings of , a 4th century monk, that precisely described not just the mood but the course it would run and the damage it could do:

"The demon of acedia -- also called the noonday demon -- is the one that causes the most serious trouble of all. . . . He makes it seem that the sun barely moves, if at all, and . . . he instills in the heart of the monk a hatred for the place, a hatred for his very life itself." ...


hey, i can relate! so, i read the whole article, and it was frankly fascinating. i kind of want to read the book too. i think nihilism might be, like, the little sister of acedia? (like how sleep is the little brother of death or whatev.) at least that's what i was thinking after the ramones' "i don't care" popped into my head while i was deciding what to call this post (excellent live clip on the title link; original album audio here). it's not a perfect fit -- sure, there's a kind of bored quality to the drone of the riff and chord changes, and the lyrics are all, "i don't care about this world." but when joey asserts "i don't care about that girl," you're thinking, "oh yes you DO, dude."

but, anyway. yeah. acedia, not depression. not the same as "carbona not glue" ... but enough with the ramones refs, awreddy.

Tuesday, September 16, 2008

it takes two



yesterday the times of london published excerpts from e-mails between doctor who revamper russell t. davies and benjamin cook, his co-author on a book about RTD's experiences with DW. one comment RTD made about young actor russell tovey -- "i think i'd make him the eleventh doctor" -- set the blogosphere and UK press a-buzzing. all on the strength of what seemed to me a passing comment of admiration and interest in this fab thesp, who played midshipman frame in last year's christmas ep, "voyage of the damned," and who i totally lurved in the pilot for being human. (hurry up and make more eps of that, BBC.)

yeah. well. i just read today's installment (or, technically, tomorrow's) of these exchanges, and believe me -- we ain't seen nothin' yet. WARNING: the preceding link contains MAJOR MAJOR spoilers for the upcoming christmas special. and i mean MAJOR. not to mention, RTD says something about the S4 two-fer "silence in the library"/"forest of the dead" that even writer/future showrunner steven moffat had been slightly more coy about. but forget that part. the christmas special: OMFG!!!!!!!

let the UK media feeding frenzy begin.

Wednesday, September 10, 2008

lost souls



rumors persist of a doctor who movie. they all seem to originate from one place, howev: reports in the UK's sun tabloid. not, i understand, the most reliable source. supposedly tennant wants to do movies, and he'll return for the 2010 season if they take the doctor big-screen. idk. it's plausible, i suppose.

and also re the 2009 specials (also via the sun), some familiar faces allegedly will be coming back (click to be spoiled). another sun report claims an even more surprising return for next year (again, click for spoilage) ... and that sketchy description makes it sound like a flashback episode ... idk II. this seems plausible too, mainly 'cause i've heard fanboy spec on this before, but somewhat more unlikely.

lots of media fuss about CERN's gigantic particle accelerator, the large hadron collider, which they started up today (super-cool above picture nicked from the CERN site). there's even a torchwood radio episode called "lost souls" that was made as part of the hoopla surrounding CERN. it was unfortunately sort of cheesy and, like, textbooky -- but it had some angst and innuendo ... and martha. so, OK.

Wednesday, September 03, 2008

...baby one more time



ohboy. there's so much to catch up on, but i don't feel all that arsed to blab.

or maybe it's more like, i feel i should start thinking about more serious matters (hey, summer's unofficially over, after all). but i don't even know where to start with the whole sarah palin thing. (she's pictured above with running mate john mccain, in a new york times photo by jim wilson.) it really seems to show the repubs' contempt for women -- or, really, for voters. one of my friends said her dad's theory is that mccain doesn't actually WANT to win. wahaha. i read in (i think) the NYT that he would've rather gone with ridge or lieberman (!?! proof of insanity), but the "base" contingent wouldn't let him and wanted palin. so, maybe a better theory is that they twisted his arm, and when she disclosed the pregnant teen daughter, he told 'em, "too bad, i'm running with her anyway!"

sigh. see? it's still summer in my brain: i can't even be serious about serious stuff. i mean, palin is totally unqualified to be vice president, just experience-wise alone. and then you have her ostrich views on global warming, her creationism, her opposition to gay marriage, the possible scandals she's linked to ... not to mention her thing for abstinence-only sex ed (yeah, THAT worked out great). i think the pregnant teen daughter is relevant, given palin's backward views on educating kids about sex, but i guess i'm with lindsay lohan on this: all the blather about it is just distracting us from the real issues.

still. the story i really want more of (assuming it IS a story, and don't you think it is?) is the one about how the palins shotgunned unsuspecting baby daddy levi into marrying their girl (or at least agreeing to act like he will). mwahaha. dude. i bet you REALLY wish you'd used a condom right about now.

Tuesday, August 19, 2008

the waiting



guess what, doctor who fans? itunes now has classic eps available for download -- stuff that's NOT EVEN OUT ON DVD!!!

i discovered this the other day and immediately downloaded a third doctor (jon pertwee) serial called "terror of the autons" -- featuring the first appearance of the ever-evil master. (and i must say, roger delgado in the role rules like a ruling thing.)

the list of choices was relatively short (considering that there are, like, 5,284 serials from the show's 400-year history), but it included some fourth doctor (tom baker) ones too. i snagged one called "the sun makers" that featured the wonderful leela and was a totally cracked commentary on the evils of capitalism, yay. (yeah, RTD knows how to yank the heartstrings and up the melodrama, but the tom baker years really brought the subversiveness, baby.)

so i thought, "boy, wouldn't it be awesome if they had 'the deadly assassin'?" you know, the 4th doc one where the master frames him for murdering the lord president of gallifrey? (the above photo, featuring ol' teeth 'n' curls in gallifreyan garb, is taken from said tale.) famed for being the only serial ever to feature the doc w/o companion? i searched for it but didn't find it, and this little link popped up that said "request anything you can't find." so i clicked it and filled out the form.

literally the next day, i went back for another hit of my favorite TV crack. and lo, what to my wondering eyes should appear but a download offering "the deadly assassin"?!? (interestingly, all three of the serials i just mentioned were written by the prolific robert holmes.) you better believe i clicked that link. haven't watched it yet, but, boy, am i looking forward to it. itunes rocks. the only thing i don't get is why these serials are rated "TV-14." that's just nuts.

Thursday, August 07, 2008

have you got it in you?



when i read last year that david tennant (star of doctor who) was going to play hamlet this summer/fall at the RSC's theater in stratford-upon-avon, i thought, "hmmm, that would be a cool thing to see." but when i read that patrick stewart (captain picard of star trek: the next generation) was also going to be in the play (as claudius/the ghost) ... i knew i had to be there. my TWO fave sci-fi tv heroes (pictured above -- DT at left -- in a rehearsal photo from the RSC) in one shakespeare production?! chance of a lifetime! so, a whole eight months ago, i bought a ticket to that play and to love's labour's lost, also featuring tennant (though, alas, not stewart), as berowne. i figured i might as well get the whole package if i'm traveling that far.

david tennant as the doctor is the most popular ever to play the role -- even leaving longtime champ tom baker in the dust (although, WTF, tom baker will always be MY doctor ...). so naturally, his casting created a sensation -- pretty much anything DT does creates a sensation, as he is a huge star in the UK. it's been a total media frenzy over there for months. (nobody but fellow doctor who fans knows who tennant is on this side of the pond, howev.) tickets are sold out (and allegedly going for up to 500 pounds on ebay). and there was the inevitable backlash, with veteran stage director sir jonathan miller criticizing the stunt casting of celebs in shakespeare (jude law is gonna play hamlet in the west end not long after tennant's done). he pouted that director gregory doran had hired "that man from doctor who" to star in his modern-dress production strictly b/c of star power. there may be some truth to this, but tennant, like stewart of course, has already done some willie the shake for the RSC before (including romeo and juliet). and now they are doin' it together (RSC production photo):



anyway, previews started last week, and the official opening was tuesday. in short, the reviews are in.

the general consensus is, "that man from doctor who" is very good, with caveats. stewart is universally getting high praise for his perf. and director doran is being universally dinged for some of the cuts he's made to the text (charles spencer in the telegraph called the play "sometimes brutally cut"). including, apparently, not revealing the fate of rosencrantz and guildenstern, who are killed by hamlet (c'mon, there can't be spoilers! this is shakespeare!).

benedict nightingale in the times gave the production four out of five stars and said tennant kept him "riveted throughout" -- although he'd seen "bolder hamlets and more moving hamlets." but nightingale was more forgiving of tennant not reaching a certain depth than other critics.

like charles spencer in the telegraph, who had many good things to say -- and also found stewart to be exemplary -- but added that "Tennant isn't in the pantheon of the great Hamlets yet."

"What's lacking, at present, is weight and depth. He delivers the great soliloquies with clarity, but he doesn't always discover their freight of emotion."

spencer gives examples of problems with "to be or not to be" and the "nunnery" speech. but he adds that tennant is best when he does tap into his emotions and has some advice:

"As the run continues, Tennant should trust his feelings, dig deeper, expose more of himself."

giving us a little bit of a feel for what it was like to be in the theater, paul taylor in the independent described the crowd and added that having tennant play hamlet was good for everyone:

"It's a joy to see Stratford's vast Courtyard Theatre packed to the rafters and liberally sprinkled with children who remain rapt throughout."

taylor finds tennant adept at most aspects of the role but notes he "excels when the prince becomes a prankish provocateur." he certainly gives the actor high marks but, similar to spencer, also says he wouldn't "put him in the absolute front rank of contemporary Hamlets" (to taylor, these would include simon russell beale, mark rylance, and stephen dillane). his reservations are in line with spencer's as well:

"In the soliloquies, the finest performers seem to be, partly, laying bare their own souls to us, too and laying us bare to ourselves. At the moment, that strange double-feeling of exposure and spiritual connection is not as strong here as one could wish here."

but he also thinks tennant is capable of getting better at this aspect of the performance.

another four out of five stars from michael billington in the guardian. he seemed especially taken with tennant, calling him "immensely engaging." and yet still ...

"If there is any quality I miss, it is the character's philosophical nature, and here he is not helped by the production."

the major party pooper was quentin letts of the daily mail, who called tennant (with much reluctance, one sensed) "memorable" but "not the greatest Dane" (groan ... oh, yes, he diiiiid). this critic was generally quite snarky about tennant's perf (while also complaining about doran's cuts, and praising stewart). but, frankly, this dude sounded like nothing but an asshole when he said:

"On Monday night I saw about 30 members of the audience leap to their feet at the end to show delight at Mr Tennant's performance. All but two of them were women.

Maybe it's because he's such a TV pin-up or maybe his interpretation of Hamlet (light on power politics, heavier on personal hiatus) is likely to appeal more to the female mind.


so you'll excuse me if -- after a totes sexist and flippin' stupid statement like that -- i don't take his sour words all that seriously.

finally, this mostly descriptive and praiseworthy take from caroline briggs of BBC news also nodded to the notion that tennant has room to improve. (at this link is a clip showing tennant coming to the stage door afterward, signing programs, and there is indeed a mob of people waiting.)

i suppose this is good news for tennant (and i know i'm relieved ... how much would it suck to make plans to travel so far, only to see something crappy?). dunno if he'll read the reviews, or heed the advice. one thing we know for sure, howev, is he still looks good in a tux:



anyway. it certainly seems possible that this notion the critics have of tennant needing to dig deeper could be viewed as a challenge -- something he genuinely seems to relish as an actor. i figure by the time i get there to see it, he'll have it all worked out.

Wednesday, August 06, 2008

all sparks



last night i went with 00soul, coiledsoul, and mimi to the opening of eddie izzard's "stripped" at the kodak theatre, which is there through saturday. what's with the hot tux and skin-flashing in the ad, eddie? you wore faded jeans, a striped shirt, and a tailcoat with a red lining (loved it!) on stage, and didn't take ANYTHING off. and the show wasn't exactly revealing on any other level, either.

whatevs. he performed on a set that was perhaps meant to evoke stone tablets (there was some shtick involving moses), or a prison cell (what with the painted-on small barred window at the back of the set, where the "outside" scene shifted from a sunrise to a big eye peering in to the moon rolling slowly by), and the show basically amounted to eddie izzard's (extremely nonlinear) history of the world, part 1. as learned on wikipedia and the internet -- ahaha.

he was very funny, but the show was pretty loose. i mean, it's long been part of EI's thing to ramble off on a tangent for many minutes and then make a motor-type noise (as though speeding back to the point) and go, "uh, where was i ... OH! noah's ark ... ." so, it wasn't so much the patented meandering, but the not-so-easy-to-hide lack of much depth. we all agreed we'd have liked more focus, not necessarily in the presentation, but in the sense that he didn't have a lot to say. beyond "vote for barack obama" and "humans have a lotta potential" -- which, great, but is that it?

oh, well. much of the nearly two-hour show was hilarious, especially that noah's ark stuff, including some recurring squirrel shtick ... a bit about "jazz chickens" ... the assortment of sound effects he made ... some wordplay involving latin, hannibal, and elephants ... and his routine about the stone age. still, it felt a little bit lazy, with a strong whiff of resting on his laurels about it. like he was content to just be "eddie izzard" and not really push things forward. which, ok -- i guess that happens to everyone. and it's been a long time since i wrote that cover story about him (never mind the mess made of the headlines and subheads in the online presentation) -- nearly five years, in fact. but in it he did speak of wanting to "... really push it, because when you get in a comfort zone, it's bad."

i wouldn't call "stripped" bad, but it's certainly not his best. oh, well. i guess they can't all be "dress to kill." but, then again, why not?

Monday, August 04, 2008

you know i'm no good



summer is the time for guilty pleasures -- and i've got one. it's a tv show called secret diary of a call girl -- based on the book, based on the blog by the pseudonymous high-priced london prostitute belle de jour (or the facsimile thereof, depending on who you believe -- i don't really see why she couldn't be real, but what do i know?). the half-hour drama (originally an ITV production out of the UK) airs on showtime after weeds on monday nights, and it stars billie piper, the once and future rose tyler from doctor who.

i started reading the blog way back when, basically for the sex and b/c belle is a lively, intelligent writer. my fave parts were (duh) the tales from her job and the outings and other social/emotional machinations with her friends. her love life was a little more frustrating to read about, mainly b/c she seemed to hook up with some real tools. anyway, then i bought the book, which was basically the blog with a few extra bits. so, naturally, i had to see the show. it's a lot, er, fluffier than the blog -- in that the show pretty much sticks to the working-girl nuts-and-bolts, the task of hiding her profession from friends/family, and one central relationship of hannah's (belle's "real" name in the show, although IRL we don't know who she is).

the show is tamer and sort of a gloss: entertaining and not very deep, sexy and soapy and a bit of a train wreck, but still watchable. plus it has an amy winehouse tune as the theme song -- although, sadly, the series doesn't really delve into blog belle's serious music jones -- and a lot of underwear and cool outfits to look at (and london!). it's a total softcore confection, with a core lightheartedness that makes every new pushing of belle's boundaries feel like a pleasant sunny romp.

the idea of a hooker who really loves to fuck and make money for it has sparked debate in some quarters about the sex trade and forced prostitution and glamorizing exploitation and blah blah blah. things to which i am certainly not insensitive. but (a) the character of belle isn't being exploited and, while (b) she may arguably have issues with integrating her entire personality/life (mostly out of necessity due to societal mores etc. etc.), ultimately (c) this show is just too frothy, for the most part -- although it has its weird and occasionally even scary moments -- to see it through a political/social lens. besides, that would harsh my mellow.

the blog belle had a lot more friends, which makes the tv belle seem curiously isolated. it's a side effect of compressing the many characters from the blog/book into one dude, ben, who is belle's best mate and former college BF. he is getting married to someone else, but apparently he still digs hannah. anyway, tv belle doesn't really hang out with anyone else besides ben, or go to the pub/restaurants/parties with a bigger circle of friends like blog belle. also, blog belle had a BF, but tv belle does not. she's sort of a cipher, other than being frank about whatever aspect of her call-girl gig she's schooling us in.

billie piper looks great and has a kind of game mischievousness about her, but she isn't always that compelling as belle. she does at times bring a nuance here and there, mostly making hannah seem possibly also still into ben and, on occasion, somewhat wistful about not having a "normal" life ... things that seem very different from the blog belle. anyway, billie does possess a natural charisma, yet she doesn't project the sort of fierce intelligence and wit, and carefree sexuality, that the best blog belle does/did (she still blogs but isn't a call girl anymore). oh, well. i'm still kind of hooked on it.

there were only eight eps in the series, and showtime's airing the last one tonight, but there'll be endless repeats if you're curious.

Saturday, August 02, 2008

starman



the doctor who S4 finale aired yesterday in the states, and the reviews are in. i chatted briefly with l.a. times TV critic robert lloyd about the show last weekend -- and nearly accidentally spoiled him for the end. (oops, sorry, dude.) his review of the finale was (as usual) very good. i loved this line:

[The show] can be very silly, usually on purpose, but it can also make you -- by which I mean me -- cry.

yes!

he also praised catherine tate/donna noble, and i wholeheartedly concur (which gives me an excuse to run another photo of her above, with the supreme dalek and the doc).

but then there's this news story about what's next for who, particularly WRT how the sci fi channel (which airs the current season here) sees the future of the series on the network. the article implies that showrunner russell t. davies has already stepped down and also says:

But "Doctor Who" will not shoot new episodes for a year and won't return to the BBC until 2010.

that's just totally wrong. there will be four episodes -- called "specials" by the producers, but they're still hour-long episodes -- shot next year (the first one beginning in january, or so i read), and they will air on the BBC next year. RTD, who is still showrunner till they start filming the 2010 season, even recently told doctor who magazine who the writers will be.

one can quibble as to whether these specials are "episodes" -- they are not discussed as being part of S4 (box set out in the US november 18) or S5, but they most certainly are doctor who and most certainly will be filmed/aired on BBC in 2009.

with robert's nice big review, it seems like the paper has decided the show is something its readers are interested in. too bad reporter choire sicha didn't think to ask the sci fi channel people if they will be picking up the 2009 specials -- something US fans would most likely want to know, no? then again, he didn't even mention these specials. it's like he didn't even know about them. i find that hard to believe, but you never know.

whatevs. luckily, i don't get my DW news from the l.a. times.

Thursday, July 31, 2008

dance along the edge



oh. right. there was a 5.4 earthquake in socal two days ago. i noticed a lot of my friends blogged about it -- even the ones who claimed not to really be arsed. and my dad called to find out if i was ok. i didn't call him back till the next day. (sorry, dad!)

hmmm. apparently i've lived here so long that such things barely even register anymore. i mean, i did feel it, and when the second bounce was bigger than the first i even got into the doorway (cuz it was right next to my chair). and i laughed at the cat, who dove under the coffee table and then came out ready to fight whatever it was that was shakin' her domain. but, yknow. here in the canyon the lights didn't flicker, nothing fell, the internet stayed on, and cell service was all ok. (even at the epicenter, damage wasn't horrible.) la vie continue.

Saturday, July 26, 2008

mama weer all crazee now



after the panels, we spent the rest of thursday wandering around the con ctr. the trade show in the main hall was overwhelmingly jammed with humans, both in costume and not. many went for authenticity, others for camp value -- like this "stormtrooper elvis" in the photo above (by mimi, like everything in this post). my favorite touch was the belt:



it reminded me of many years ago, when some friends and i checked out a star trek convention at a local hotel, and across the hall was an elvis convention. i got a great shot of a klingon and a vegas-elvis together, which at the time seemed hilariously strange.

anyway, so ... we made a beeline for the bbc america booth and loaded up on toys. we considered huge sets of daleks, sonic screwdrivers, a face of boe, and the voice-activated dalek, but eventually i settled for the con-"exclusive" action figures of the ninth doctor and the tenth/fifth set from "time crash" (where peter davison's doctor is styled as he was in his prime, and not with the paunch and receded hairline of his actual appearance in that special). but my favorite thing is this tiny little TARDIS cell-phone charm:



it spins around and flashes a blue light whenever i make or receive a call or a text (and sometimes at random moments, which is fun). they also had a teeny dalek, but i just had to have my very own TARDIS in a jar. yeah.

we looked at endless amounts of t-shirts, but nothing really grabbed us. we did find a guy selling patches; she snagged a slytherin one and a robin (as in batman and robin) one, and i got a doctor who logo from the tom baker years. awes! we were frustrated in our search for buttons, though. i thought that was so weird -- putting tiny badges on one's jacket is as hip as it was 20 years ago when i was a youth, and yet we saw hardly anyone selling them or giving them away. (but one place did have an excellent eyeball button, which i scooped up for a buck.) maybe we just weren't looking in the right places -- the room was huge.

we visited the sci-fi channel pavilion, DC and marvel, dark horse (where much umbrella academy stuff was purchased by mimi ... including buttons!), top shelf, fantagraphics, and so many more i can't remember them all. also stopped by the booth of my pal mary fleener and her artist friend scott saw to chat for a while.

and we saw cylons, both old-school ones:



and new models:



plus a version of puppet-angel from that crazy evil-children's-show episode of angel called "smile time":



later, amid the merch vendors, we saw an apparently official puppet-spike doll too, but i don't remember spike getting turned into a puppet. that was a long time ago, though, so i could be wrong.

naturally, there was the requisite star wars audience-participation floor show:



and, of course, lego versions of star wars stuff (pretty impressive kit, i'd say):



what we didn't see a lot of, all things considered, was comic books. tucked away in a corner of the hall, somewhere between the small-press folks and the goth-clothing vendor, were a relative handful of people with the familiar long, narrow cardboard boxes holding actual funnybooks. "silver age comics -- 50% off!" read one sign. that was actually kind of depressing. my only other trip to the con was all ABOUT tracking down reasonably priced golden ages and searching out missing issues of the alan moore swamp thing -- a treasure hunt that i'd imagine few people even bother to participate in nowadays, what with the reprint collections making it so much easier to read the old stuff from any era.

still, i was amazed that so many people were there to get their geek on, in whatever form that meant. i loved seeing the people in costume and how much care so many took to get the details right (the old-school cylon above and his mates even had helmets with the red light and the sound effects). but i am still getting used to the notion that geekness is cool. (i still can't forget that TV ad for the LOTR fellowship DVDs from several years ago, with the little kid turning to his dad and going, "gandalf is THE MAN!")

OTOH, it makes total sense that comic book movies and other fantasy properties are so popular right now. i suppose some of the appeal of superhero tales is that you can imagine yourself with that kind of power. but i also think that, in the fifth year of a war that has gone from being supported by nearly everyone to being suspected by almost all of us ... where we exist in a black-and-white world full of grey areas ... such stories are bound to be appealing. these days, not insignificantly, a lot of them feature heroes who struggle with their own morality and motives, or simply have their own (possibly questionable) codes -- although others are more clearly drawn. still, they all offer the classic good-vs.-evil, where good is guaranteed to eventually win, even if it has to get bashed around and crack open some heads in the process. there's also the more escapist, romantic stuff like twilight, but even the supernatural love jazz has its conflicts and battles, its triumphs over adversity and trouble. they all provide an escape while tapping into the zeitgeist desire for a better world, since things in this one are so hard and bleak. plus, frankly, the stories have resolutions, and real life doesn't. even in the really dark stuff, like battlestar galactica, there's a sense of moving toward something and reaching it, whatever might happen. in real life, things get bogged down and drag on and don't seem to change much (except maybe to get worse, while still not being resolved). it's enough to make anyone wanna dress up like a vegas stormtrooper, fer shur.

Friday, July 25, 2008

the happening



went to the san diego comic-con yesterday -- just for the first day of the weekend-long event. a couple of weeks ago, i saw there were going to be panels on doctor who and torchwood. this is bbc america's first foray to the con; as TW is its most successful show ever, it makes sense that the net would want a presence there. anyway, i bought a ticket for thursday, and later mimi managed to snag one too -- the event sold out not long after we bought 'em. i rented a car for the drive, and we went down there on wednesday night. we made it to the con ctr in time to pick up our badges in advance that evening (OMG the line), then met up with a couple of artist pals of hers from new york city, who generously let us crash at their hotel.

i haven't been to a con since the late '80s. i knew it had gotten a lot bigger, but the scale of it was a fully overwhelming, sensory-overloaded, trance-inducing, at times alarming (due to sheer crush of humanity, mainly) but usually delightful experience. we got into the con ctr around 10:30 on thursday morning, secured coffee, and sat in on the virgin comics panel featuring stan lee and grant morrison -- mainly b/c it was in the same ballroom that the DW/TW panels were in right afterward, and we wanted to make sure we got seats. stan lee is a self-aggrandizing old coot -- yeah, yeah, and a comics legend, blah blah blah -- but grant morrison was game, not to mention charming in his suit.

various fan were dressed as characters from the two shows, including several tenth doctors. at one point a whole parade of different doctors walked by -- one, three, four, six, and ten. what a groovy sight. later on, mimi and i spotted the fan in the above photo (by mimi) dressed perfectly like ten -- brown pinstripes, patterned tie, pale dress shirt, cream-colored converse, camel coat ... not to mention spiky hair. and when we asked to take his picture, he busted out the sonic screwdriver and struck a pose -- so awes!

i had decided to embark on this whole endeavor b/c i wanted to hear DW reimaginer/head writer/producer russell t. davies talk. but he wasn't on the panel. (he apparently had to stay behind and write the rest of TW S3.) i knew this going in b/c i had inside info. but i thought it was weird that, although it was known at least a week ago (and maybe more) that he wouldn't be there, the official con website schedule was never updated to show this.

anyway, so, it turned out ok, b/c the DW panel DID feature writer steven moffat (who's penned such brill eps as "blink," "the empty child"/"the doctor dances," "the girl in the fireplace," and "silence in the library"/"forest of the dead"), who will be taking over show-running for the 2010 season, and executive producer julie gardner, who is also a bigwig at BBC TV and BBC wales. both were great, and i ended up almost glad that RTD wasn't there, b/c it put the spotlight on moffat (a scot, like DW star david tennant and, actually, grant morrison). he and julie had a sort of running bit about some apparent troubles he'd had getting into the country for the con. he joked at one point that he thought the doctor's sending his "clingy girlfriend" to another dimension with his clone was a clever way to get rid of her. (hmm, i sense they're done with billie piper, then?) and he generally took on the fans with good humor but wasn't afraid to poke fun at some ideas and comments -- even while flatly rejecting any overtures for the slightest detail of what he has planned for the show.

they showed a montage of clips from who eps moffat wrote (but -- boo! -- not from the eccleston two-fer "the empty child"/"the doctor dances" ... i hope it wasn't b/c someone decided, "whatever. that doctor is sooo four seasons ago.") and, later, we got the full trailer for the '08 christmas special (featuring cybermen, bleah, but still looking like it's gonna be cool) -- the only piece of preview footage shown (they got nothing else to show ... i mean, the sarah jane adventures weren't part of it, although there is a brief trailer for SJA S2 now.) it has a seemingly sinister female in it, and i taunted mimi that it might be the rani at last.

the panelists had a brief chat session before taking questions from the audience. most of these were of the "how do you come up with your ideas?" and, "will we be seeing more of _____ [river song, the doctor's daughter, etc.] in S5?" (not telling.) and, will all the episodes be as scary as "blink," "silence in the library"/"forest of the dead," etc.? (maybe.) his answer about whether or not river song recognized "the essence" of the doctor or the actual tennant doctor was interesting: he said that she had met the tennant doctor but "that's not the only doctor she's met." hmm. so she met tennant's doctor, and then he regenerated at some point? maybe? would be a clever way to keep his options open, i suppose.

one person referenced "time crash" and asked if moffat would consider writing a longer story featuring some of the other actors who've played the doctor. he said he thought such a thing could be dispatched in 8 minutes (a la "time crash") and added that the story would have to be worth more than the novelty of two different versions of the same man meeting. (backstory: there have apparently been rumors, or wishful thinking, or something, about a "three doctors" with paul mcgann, christopher eccleston, and david tennant.) yeah? well, i've got an idea! they all somehow get dragged back to the time war and end up saving gallifrey. b/c frankly, all this last-of-the-time-lords stuff has run its course. bring back the time lords, so the doctor can have someone messing with HIS life once in a while! plus, it would be a great story for those three, b/c it seems likely that mcgann's doctor went through the time war, eccleston's is the regeneration from whatever happened to him in it, and tennant is the still-processing-it-all doctor.

someone else brought up SJA and the spoiler about another old who supporting character coming back on that show (click the link if you want to know), and asked if there were plans to bring back anyone else. moffat rather aggressively stated that the show is really for the new crop of 8-year-olds who come to it every year, and not about nostalgia. this may be an insight into how he will want to shape the show -- although i don't think he meant that there's no value in tapping into the show's history or the longtime cultural love affair with it. RTD has certainly been forward-looking with who, but part of the appeal for him was definitely, and specifically, nostalgic. and he played to that sentiment for viewers too: bringing back all the old villains, and some old friends, and even an earlier version of the doctor. by contrast, moffat's nostalgia for the series seems more rooted in the effect the show had on him as a kid, the lasting impression it left -- mostly the scary-creepy impression.

indeed, moffat's take on the whoniverse seems to be that, as mimi later summed it up, "everything is canon, and nothing is canon." which makes for exciting possibilities. the only thing i want never to happen, ever, is for the doctor's true name to be revealed. other than that, go for it.

the TW panel was a much different animal, mainly due to the presence of john "captain jack" barrowman. as they say in the old school, he's a pistol! he came charging out, leaped up on his chair, and waved his arms in the air like he just didn't care. his short black polo shirt rode up, exposing his white belt (!) and white belly, and he pretended like he was going to moon us, but didn't. and that was just the entrance. here he is below (second from left) in this close-up from my one half-decent shot of the panel, grinning mischievously:



julie gardner stayed on for the TW panel (more photos from it in this report from the con), and they were joined by gareth david-lloyd (who plays torchwood righthand man/jack's lover ianto jones) wearing a black portishead t-shirt, and naoko mori (who played toshiko sato, until her character was killed off this season). it was a rollicking good time, although the clip reel they showed from S2 ended with tosh's death scene, which was truly devastational. the lights came up, and barrowman was wiping his eyes, gareth had his head in his hands, and everyone in the crowd was like, "bummer!" JB commented that it was hard to watch that scene, and indeed they had had a hard time shooting it, b/c they weren't just losing a character from the show but a family member (i've read this sentiment before in interviews). but he praised naoko's acting -- she actually seemed like the least shook up by seeing the scene again, which was interesting. or maybe she's just better at covering her emotions.

anyway, the fan Q&A included the cringeworthy moment when one guy said he finally got to get on his knees for captain jack -- OMG, no he diiiidn't!! and the totes charming part where someone noted that JB had earlier mentioned appearing in miss saigon with naoko, so now could they please sing some of their duet "sun and moon"? ahaha! they actually did "the last night of the world," somewhat haltingly in terms of remembering the lyrics at first, but naoko sang purely, and by the end JB got on track, and it was rather lovely, actually, with a sweet melancholy to it.

gardner said that the next TW series (which is only five eps long) will be all one big story, and that really bad things will happen. OMG, they killed off half the team last season -- how much worse can it GET? and -- can't wait to find out!

i was really struck by how much all of these people seemed truly enthusiastic and happy in their jobs. it's not surprising, of course -- both shows are great, and really popular in the UK. some of the joy comes from being successful, but also, i think, especially for the people who grew up loving who (like moffat and barrowman), it's the bliss of getting to be a part of something that meant so much to them. even as a viewer, that's one of the charms of the modern whoniverse for me -- seeing this show i used to love as a kid brought back to even more exceptional and brilliant life. also, the camaraderie among the three TW actors felt genuine, although frankly i can imagine that dealing with barrowman's over-the-top personality all day, every day might be wearing after a while.

this concludes the panels portion of my comic-con report. there's more to say about the carnival that was the trade show (and the stuff i bought), but i'll save it for the next post.

Monday, July 21, 2008

planet of sound



i saw this item about "doctor who" theme creator delia derbyshire the other day on the news page of outpost gallifrey (or gallifrey one or whatever they call themselves). it seemed interesting, but it wasn't till after the doc sent it to me that i actually followed the link and fully checked it out. the BBC news story -- which focuses on a new archive of 267 tapes of her work found in her attic after she died in 2001 -- talks about how she was working at the BBC's radiophonic workshop in 1963 and was given the theme to work on. (that's her up there, at the beeb back in the day.)

the theme is credited to composer ron grainer, but the sound is all hers. as recounted in this bio on her official site:

On first hearing it Grainer was tickled pink: "Did I really write this?" he asked. "Most of it," replied Derbyshire.

and let's not forget that, like the TARDIS itself, the theme music has scarcely changed since 1963. why mess with perfection?

a really cool thing about the BBC news story is that it has sound clips, including one of "a piece of music that sounds like a contemporary dance track which was recorded, it is believed, in the late sixties." it does sound rather mind-blowingly contemporary.

she was a genius, but if she'd taken the status quo at face value, doctor who would likely have a very different-sounding theme song. in a way, it's surprising her name is even known.

In 1959, on approaching Decca records, Delia was told that the company DID NOT employ women in their recording studios, so she went to work for the UN in Geneva before returning to London to work for music publishers Boosey & Hawkes.

In 1960 Delia joined the BBC as a trainee studio manager. She excelled in this field, but when it became apparent that the fledgling Radiophonic Workshop was under the same operational umbrella, she asked for an attachment there - an unheard of request, but one which was, nonetheless,granted. Delia remained 'temporarily attached' for years, regularly deputising for the Head, and influencing many of her trainee colleagues.


delia's story is fascinating, so do check out the link to her site, and also this fansite/catalog (from whence i nicked a nice-sized version of the photo seen in the article). she worked with a lot of artists and also did sound for "happenings" and theatrical productions, including one of hamlet at the roundhouse in london in 1969 (sound clip at the BBC story link). ahaha. i'll bet david tennant's hamlet -- which opens thursday at the RSC in stratford-upon-avon -- won't have anywhere near as wiggy a soundscape.

Sunday, July 20, 2008

this ain't the summer of love



saw the dark knight yesterday afternoon at the vista in silver lake. love that theater -- with its crazy neon-colored egyptian-deco decor, nice big seats and lots of leg room, and popcorn with real butter. not to mention, the manager was dressed up like batman and taking tickets at the door. "the batmanager!" i quipped, getting a big laff from coiledsoul and mimi.

anyway. the movie was really fab. a bit long, but mostly entertaining, with awesome bat-moments and some really crazy stunts that made me laugh with delight and disbelief (as in, "oh no they diiiidn't!!"). heath ledger made a very good joker (that's him up there, about to get whaled on by christian bale's batman), although the whole lip-licking thing was a little weird, but whatev. the opening sequence was fantabulous, and a nice way of conveying the new gotham criminal (loony costumed freak) overtaking the old gotham criminal (basically, mobsters). also, aaron eckhart made a good harvey dent (aka two-face) -- his makeup after he went supervillain was super-creepy (exactly like the comic art) and left me wondering how they did it.

although it had humor and moments of triumph and whatnot, the movie was not really a feel-good comic-book romp. which, neither was batman begins, christopher nolan's first batman movie. this isn't a criticism -- i don't think batman movies should be larks. christian bale isn't a chiseled hero like george clooney (whose batman chapter was unfortunately horrendous), but he's good-looking and suave enough to pull off the bruce wayne part, and he works pretty well in the suit (hey, at least he has a chin ... lookin' at you, keaton). he's attractive in a totally non-pretty way, and his look really fits this movie that is rather relentlessly intense. i mean -- the finest batman stories are like that; the caped crusader has never really been about lofty ideals like truth, justice, and the american way. well, maybe justice.

batman's heroism is born of damage and desperation ... it really comes from one moment of reaction that he forever after attempts to turn into action. it always goes back to little bruce wayne watching his parents die at the hands of a two-bit thug -- a trigger-happy, cowardly criminal. the batman spends the rest of his days trying to erase such scum from the city, even though it'll never bring his parents back. he can't right the wrong; he can only make them pay and pay and pay. and it's never enough. i mean, batman is my favorite superhero. but i do think it's especially interesting right now to consider the nature of vigilantism and waging an open-ended one-man war -- and the consequences and costs of same. (but that's too much like mixing politics into my fun -- which is nowhere near as delicious as getting your chocolate in my peanut butter.)

the whole thing was very, well, dark. it delved into the question of whether batman -- a new kind of crimefighter -- had actually brought into existence, along with himself, such creatures as the joker -- a new kind of villain. i'm dubious of this sort of reasoning, but it's a classic theme of the comic. still, there's a scene where alfred (the absolutely wonderful michael caine) is kind of schooling bruce about what he's up against with the joker, and it seems to me that alfred's story indicates that the joker isn't really anything new ... just a different flavor of psychotic evil. the joker wants to hang his whole deal on bats, but that's just the same old evil-talking-shit jive, man. it's always someone else's fault, right? whatevah.

it was totes bombtastic whenever bats jumped off buildings and went sailing into the night (and crashing through high-rise windows) with his hang-glider-esque wings. still, i could've done with a little more straight-up asskicking and a little less speeding around on the bat-bike (and all the transformers-esque trickery that went with it), but that's just me. the vehicle stunts were cool, but i prefer to see batman mixing it up with his fists, legs, knees, elbows, headbutts. he didn't get nearly beat to shit enough for my tastes, either. i never felt like batman was even close to being physically defeated in this film -- sure, he has to make hard choices, and there are ways in which he loses, big time, but, aside from one encounter with a dog early on and a fairly bone-crunching tangle with the joker toward the end, for the most part he scarcely seemed to get his costume dirty.

OTOH, there were some brutal scenes, and maybe not enough blood, considering. i'm not really a fan of gore, but this was a bit sanitary, all things considered. anyway, the dark knight was a nice big bowl of actiony eye candy -- a perfect summer movie for this bleak and broken age.

Tuesday, July 15, 2008

end of the world party



ok, here are the rest of my thoughts on the doctor who finale, which airs in the u.s. starting august 1 on sci-fi. tune out if you don't care and DON'T READ ON IF YOU DON'T WANT TO BE SPOILED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

despite my sorrow and outrage over what was done to donna, i really did enjoy "journey's end" ... even more the second time. the pack of companions was fun: interestingly, i just finished watching a DVD of the 1983 special "the five doctors" -- also chock-full of companions, as well as (more or less) all the doctors in existence up to that point. likewise, "journey's end" had most of the new series' companions (plus sarah jane and k-9 from then/now). and only two doctors. welllll, two versions of the same doctor, to be precise. anyway, just look at 'em all:



i listened to this "easter egg" DVD commentary on "the five doctors," which features david tennant, who producer phil collinson (who's actually leaving the show as of the end of this season -- wah!), and script editor/writer helen raynor. basically they drink champagne and talk about how, when they were kids, this was the most. exciting. thing. EVAR. but one of them, i think tennant, also notes that the onslaught of companions and doctors is "almost too much." in a way, so was "journey's end." it was an hour long, but so much was crammed into it. some things felt too truncated (like the rose storyline, despite the time spent on it and the resolution ... idk, i didn't feel like the "real" doctor and rose really got their moment). and some characters -- hello, gwen and ianto -- kind of got stashed away and didn't do much.

but, eh, so what? b/c: daleks!



the squirrel commented that "supreme dalek" (the one above in the middle) sounds a bit like a sandwich from burger king -- ahahaa. but his red plating was cool. crazy ol' dalek caan, hanging around naked and giggling all the time. whee! and of course the return of davros kicked up a LOT of excitement -- julian bleach made a magnificent davros, did he not?



davros taunts the doctor about emotion being a weakness (bored now), and the same sorta stuff that i recently heard the cybermen going on about in the fifth doctor ep "earthshock." but wtf: apparently, at least for the daleks, having no emotions means also having no bullshit detector. after all, they're the ones following a mad leader and his totally insane "prophet," dalek caan (who's not even on their side -- hahahaaaaaa!).

somewhat ironically, davros also blah-blahs about the doctor bringing death to multitudes (so much for emotions being a weakness?). it was a bit tiresome: just the usual evil-talking-shit (as in, he's evil, and he's talking shit!). yeah, it was cool to see davros come back (and share that warm-fuzzy moment with sarah jane ...), but in a way it was at the expense of other moments that mattered more. first off, we've been over this whole "doctor, savior or menace?" thing before, most recently in "turn left." i don't even see this rap as an effective guilt trip -- at least it wasn't in "the satan pit," when the devil hizownself taunts the doctor with much the same spiel, and our wild-haired hero doesn't even flinch. idk, maybe losing people in battle, while he lives on, is one of those things that festers in the doctor's soul ... but it's no poor reflection on him that people fight harder when he's around. besides, if we're talking about bringing death to multitudes of daleks, well, someone give that man a medal.

anyway, i've already made this argument at length, so i'll spare you further tirade.

davros makes it out like so many people have sacrificed themselves for the doctor ... as though, again, there was never anything more at stake than the doctor's life. when there often was -- including here. davros twists their intentions and mocks the doctor for turning his "children of time" into killers. well, if anything, they're soldiers (and i would prefer the word "fighters," actually) -- and there IS a difference. they're not out there trying to detonate reality bombs and wipe out everything but themselves (lookin' at YOU, davros); they're doing what they have to do to save their world. (er, not that i expect davros to approve of it. of course he's gonna proselytize against that sort of resistance, since resistance is, to the daleks, futile -- or at least it was until star trek co-opted that catchphrase for the borg, and now resistance to the daleks is merely useless.)

anyway ... once again, martha gets sent off to far-flung corners on a solitary mission, and she's her usual brave and tough self, gamely pulling the ripcord on that experimental teleportation pack and flickering off to do the hard task.



i really dug how martha pauses, before engaging the osterhagen key, to give the daleks a choice -- just like the doctor would. and also how both she AND sarah jane had ways to wreck the whole dalek plan. but, dang -- the idea of UNIT creating some protocol to blow up the world in order to save it from horrible suffering is, like, so totally the nanny state taken to its most insane extreme!! (probably the scariest thing about this episode.) whatever happened to "where there's life there's hope"?

still, martha's kind of insane devotion to duty has to be at least ONE reason why jack is heavily recruiting her to join torchwood. (i'm sure there are others ... .)



despite the companions' various i'll-blow-you-all-up stances, in the end, of course, the doctor is the most hardcore of all. well, it's doctor two who destroys every dalek ... but somebody had to.



and does the original doctor appreciate this quick-thinking, take-charge action? no, he does not. instead he yells at doctor two and tells him to "get in the TARDIS!" -- as though he were a wayward child (of time?).

OTOH ... the exchange b/w doc2 and donna in the TARDIS -- when he's giving her a hard time about not believing in herself, and she's all "stop it, doctor," but he keeps it up and kinda hurts her feelings -- underscored that he is a separate entity. the original wouldn't have done that. he's got more compassion, or restraint i guess, than his clone ... with daleks as with donna. i sometimes feel like there is some wiggling b/w whether the doctor actively needs to remind himself to be fair and kind, or if he simply does stuff like giving daleks and sontarans and giant spider-things and nestene consciousnesses a choice b/c to him that's just naturally right. maybe it's both. i suppose when you can see the whole of space and time laid out before you like a patchwork quilt, maybe a moment when the daleks won't be evil seems possible. and maybe that makes them worth trying to save. i dunno. certainly, though quite mad, dalek caan does realize how wrong the daleks are. (but, er, his solution is the same: exterminate!) maybe that gives the doctor some sort of hope.

anyway, yes. doctor two. he's got one heart, one life, and he talks like donna. no wonder the doctor leaves him in the other dimension with rose (and how come mickey can go back to his original reality, but not rose?). on one hand, it's so typical that rose finally gets her very own doctor, and he (and his hardly-used parts) wants to be with HER (b/c he's human and so can let himself feel all those feelings that the doctor can't but does). and yet rose STILL whinges that the doctor is the doctor, and this guy ain't the doctor!! which doesn't stop her kissing him. b/c, welllll, at least he actually can say he loves her.



technically, of course, rose is right. (i mean, before she asked the doctor what his last words were to her when they saw each other in bad wolf bay the first time, for a second there i thought she was going to ask him what she was supposed to call doc2 ... heh.) it's an uneasy wish-fulfillment at best, and when doc2 slips his hand into rose's at the end of that scene, it parallels what she did with the doctor as the TARDIS plunged to its death in the dalek crucible -- but i also couldn't help thinking of the ending of the graduate.



it's sort of sweet when the doctor says, "he needs you, and that's very me." those are fairy-tale words, though, and they don't really match the strange sense of uncertainty in that shot. rose did help the doctor, but it was always a two-way street. and, sure, doc2 has much to give rose, but is she always gonna think of him as not HIM? anyway, the idea of just saying, essentially, "you can fix him" feels -- not even so much sexist as just incredibly old-fashioned.

at any rate, with the arrival of doc2, mickey's decision to go back to his original reality shows he's hardly an idiot (although he long ago disproved that anyway).



like martha, mickey knows he has to get the hell away from the object of his unrequited love (ie, rose) if he's ever going to get over her. now, i know that martha has a fiance and all, but if she and mickey really end up on torchwood together (and don't you think they will?), could sparks fly? they don't really seem like each other's types, but think about gwen and owen. TOTALLY wrong for each other -- and totally, freakishly HOT together. so ... given all the sexual frisson that's gone before, we can always hope for a little martha/mickey action in the bowels of the hub somewhere, or out on some lonely patrol, or in the middle of a firefight, or ... . (actually, i suspect it would be more like the tosh/owen thing, with mickey being gaga over martha and her being all "whatevs.")

i always enjoy the ways in which RTD and the other writers set up the season's arc early on and let threads dangle throughout the run. but the more i think about rose and her trying to contact the doctor etc. etc., the more that seems like a distraction. i mean, the real climax was donna becoming part time lord for a while and transcending her humanity and saving the universe ... at a cost (shades of bad wolf, i suppose). and for a while, all vectors in the multiverse pointed to donna. xlnt.

i loved the way the TARDIS took matters into its own, er, doors -- trapping donna inside so that she could effect the creation of doc2 and save it. (so, strictly speaking, that actually WAS "time lord treachery.") i'd like to see more character development for the TARDIS -- ahaha. seriously, i do wish they'd show some more of the inside, like in the old days. OTOH, i'm not so keen on the notion that a TARDIS properly requires six pilots, but whatev.



not that i didn't enjoy the scene in the TARDIS where everybody's working their bit (donna: "that's very good, jack; i think you're the best") -- while everyone down on earth hangs on for dear life and screams and leaps about in joyous relief at being saved. but the soaring music was a bit much, and, well ... it's probably best not to get too deep into the whole TARDIS-tows-the-earth-back-home thing. it was funny, at least.

i already mentioned in the donna post the things i turned out to be right about this season (and i was also wrong about stuff, but why dwell on the negative?). i was also right that events were being manipulated by an unseen force, which turned out to be dalek caan. that's not exactly a brilliant perception, though -- it seems like every season there's a singular force behind the action.

still, i felt a little too in sync when the doctor asked torchwood gwen if she came from an old cardiff family, and he and rose meta-tastically commiserated about how much gwen reminded them, clearly, of gywneth from the ninth-doctor ep "the unquiet dead" -- which i mentioned recently.



finally, i have rashly said that i'd rather donna were dead than in her current state of unawareness. on friday i had a great chat with a fellow DW fan -- who was equally distressed by donna's fate but gently noted that at least donna not being dead means there's a chance of her coming back someday. ok, that's a good point. it doesn't seem like she will, but i am all for it, man. ALL for it.